Trump ousts defense chief Mark Esper, who balked at loyalty demand


November 10, 2020


FILE PHOTO: U.S. President Donald Trump listens to Secretary of Defense Mark Esper address the daily White House coronavirus response briefing with members of the administration’s coronavirus task force at the White House in Washington, U.S., March 18, 2020. REUTERS/Jonathan Ernst




U.S. Defense Secretary Mark Esper was fired in a tweet on Monday, as President Donald Trump went after a top aide he blamed for not supporting him sufficiently.

Trump said he’s naming Christopher Miller, the director of the National Counterterrorism Center, as acting Pentagon chief.

Esper’s relationship with Trump soured after the defense secretary resisted Trump’s inclination to use active-duty forces to quell protests in U.S. cities earlier this year.

Esper’s departure could foreshadow a broader post-election purge of appointees who displeased the president. It also means Trump will have seen the departure of two confirmed defense secretaries in less than two years. The move drew criticism from Democrats.

“Continuity and stability are always important during a presidential transition; they are absolutely imperative at this moment, as this historically erratic administration prepares for its departure,” House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said in a statement. She said the timing “raises serious questions about Trump’s planned actions for the final days of his administration.”

Mark Warner of Virginia, the top Democrat on the Senate Intelligence Committee, said he was “deeply troubled” by Esper’s firing and urged Trump not to fire anyone else in the intelligence community. Trump has hinted he may oust FBI Director Christopher Wray, and he also could remove CIA Director Gina Haspel.

“President Trump must not invite further volatility by removing any Senate-confirmed intelligence or national security officials during his time left in office,” Warner said.

Although Esper, 56, had worked with the president on controversial priorities such as sending U.S. troops to the border with Mexico and drawing down forces in Germany, Afghanistan and Syria, the president voiced increasing dissatisfaction with his Pentagon chief in recent months.

Trump said privately in August that he planned to replace Esper after the election, according to people familiar with the discussions, while the defense secretary told people close to him that he intended to leave regardless of the election’s outcome.

The White House had alerted Miller that he should be ready to become acting defense secretary. He had known since at least September, according to two people familiar with the situation.

Miller previously served as the top counterterrorism official at the White House’s National Security Council, where his portfolio was largely focused on what Trump sees as among his biggest foreign policy victories: hostage recovery and the campaign against Islamic State terrorists. He was overseeing the office when the U.S. launched a successful operation to kill Islamic State leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi.

Miller was later named deputy assistant secretary of defense for special operations and combating terrorism, and then offered the chance to run the National Counterterrorism Center. He was sworn in on Aug. 10 of this year after winning Senate confirmation on a voice vote.

A veteran of the Army Special Forces, Miller helped draft the 2018 White House counterterrorism strategy — a document that classified Iran and Hezbollah as among the threats facing the United States.

James Inhofe of Oklahoma, the Republican chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee, said in a statement that he had already spoken with Miller and looks “forward to working with him” to maintain the defense priorities that Esper helped establish. Miller was seen arriving at the Pentagon on Monday afternoon.

The president was frustrated that Esper, who became secretary in July 2019 after serving as Army secretary and as a former executive at Raytheon Technologies Corp., didn’t do more to publicly defend him on key issues, including Trump’s rejection of reports that Russia paid Taliban fighters “bounties” for the killing of U.S. troops in Afghanistan.

Trump has increasingly sought overt signs of loyalty and a willingness by his top aides to engage in partisan fighting, as demonstrated by Secretary of State Michael Pompeo’s making of a video in support of the president while on an official trip to Jerusalem that was shown at the Republican National Convention in August.

But while Trump’s Cabinet secretaries routinely shift praise for key accomplishments to the president, Esper sometimes showed neutrality. Last month, Esper lauded 10 NATO allies for meeting defense spending thresholds without mentioning that Trump had pressed for that outcome.

Trump was also angered that Esper in June publicly opposed the idea of deploying active-duty military to contain nationwide protests over racism. He confronted his defense secretary June 3 at the White House after Esper held a news conference in which he said that using active-duty military forces to perform law enforcement within the U.S. is “a matter of last resort” and that the National Guard was better-suited to the task, people familiar with the matter said.

The president again signaled fatigue with Esper on Aug. 15, when he used a derogatory nickname for his defense chief meant to suggest he’s a yes-man.

“Mark Yesper, did you call him Yesper?” Trump said at the time. “Some people call him Yesper. I get along with him,” he added with a shrug.

When asked if he was considering firing Esper, the president replied, “I consider firing everybody. At some point that’s what happens.”

In a Nov. 4 interview with Military Times that was published after he was fired, Esper rejected the “Yesper” taunt and all but boasted of his refusal to praise Trump with the effusiveness that other Cabinet members displayed.

“My frustration is I sit here and say, ‘Hm, 18 Cabinet members. Who’s pushed back more than anybody?’ Name another Cabinet secretary that’s pushed back,” he said. “Have you seen me on a stage saying, ‘Under the exceptional leadership of blah-blah-blah, we have blah-blah-blah-blah?’

He also expressed his pride in pursuing a national defense strategy that elevated the need to counter the expanding military ambitions of China and Russia over the previous preoccupation with counterterrorism.

In a farewell letter to the Defense Department’s military and civilian employees, Esper thanked them for working with him to “improve the readiness, capabilities, and professionalism of the joint force, while fundamentally transforming and preparing it for the future.” He also noted challenges they faced — from the coronavirus pandemic to “a charged political atmosphere here at home.”

Esper’s performance was praised on Monday by Sen. Deb Fischer, a Nebraska Republican who sits on the Senate Armed Services Committee. Esper “has been an effective leader for our military who understands the major threats our nation faces. It has been a pleasure working with him,” she said.

As Esper lost support in the White House, he also found himself under increasing criticism from former top defense officials. Esper and Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, came under fire for their decision to join Trump on a walk to a church across the street from the White House in early June after the park there was forcibly cleared of peaceful protesters.

Critics said Esper and Milley’s participation militarized an event that undercut freedom of speech and assembly.

Retired Adm. Mike Mullen, a former chairman of the Joint Chiefs under Presidents George W. Bush and Barack Obama, wrote in an op-ed for The Atlantic at the time that “our fellow citizens are not the enemy, and must never become so.”

In tacit criticism of the president, Esper called the event a “photo-op” and said he hadn’t realized it was going to take place.

Trump has had a tumultuous relationship with military leaders since taking office. Retired Gen. James Mattis abruptly resigned in December 2018 after the president announced plans to withdraw troops from Syria with little planning. Trump later nominated Patrick Shanahan, who withdrew from consideration in June 2019 after reports of a messy divorce years earlier surfaced.

More recently, Trump’s nominee for another top job at the Pentagon, Brig. Gen. Anthony Tata, foundered when his confirmation hearing was abruptly canceled and the White House withdrew his nomination. Tata had been dogged by controversy over his past remarks, including derogatory comments about Islam.

Esper’s tenure wasn’t significantly shorter than many of his predecessors. While Donald Rumsfeld and Robert Gates, combined, served more than 10 years in the role, most Pentagon chiefs in recent years have lasted fewer than two years. President Bill Clinton’s first secretary of defense, Les Aspin, served one year and two weeks in the position, the shortest since the Nixon administration.

Leave a Reply